Dutch electricity company Eneco won a tender offered by NS two years ago and the two companies signed a 10-year deal setting January 2018 as the date by which all NS trains should run on wind energy. Still don't like the disingenious advertisement thought. I cant help feeling that inexperienced power traders at NS will have been taken to the cleaners at the expense of passengers. Its 50Hz in the Netherlands and most of the planet apart from (mainly) the US, Canada and half of Latin America. All Dutch electric trains are now powered by wind energy, the national railway company NS has said . Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. The claim by the Dutch railway network, Nederlandse Spoorwegen (NS), is almost entirely a sleight of hand. I think the trains in the Netherlands use 1.5kVDC anyway bet there are no wind turbines producing that directly. So pick your choice The wholesale price of GOs seems to be a mere 0.36/MWh or so. It seems that NS may be outsourcing costs as well as power. [2] The Dutch are trying to meet the EU-set target of producing 14% of total energy use from renewable sources by 2020, and 16% by 2023. Rather they act like a component in an electric circuit. In an anything goes era of news and social media, its not often that a post jumps off the page. The Dutch government has set a target of 6,000 MW nameplate capacity of onshore wind power by 2020 (not met, as per the data above) and 4,450 MW of offshore wind power by 2023. The Same Reason You Would Study Anything Else, The (Mostly) Quantum Physics Of Making Colors, This Simple Thought Experiment Shows Why We Need Quantum Gravity, How The Planck Satellite Forever Changed Our View Of The Universe. Whats the trick? So how does NS justify the claim that all Dutch trains run on 100% wind power? In 2020 wind power provided 11.54% of the Dutch electricity generation (see table above) while solar power provided an additional 7.25% for a combined 18.79% - easily meeting the target without taking other renewable sources into account, even though the target for onshore wind capacity was not met. According to Railway Technology because it has a: green energy contract thought to be among the largest yet signed in Europe between power supplier Eneco and VIVENS, an energy procurement joint venture comprising Netherlands Railways (NS), Veolia, Arriva, Connexxion and rail freight firms, and because, NS and Eneco have carefully selected a list of wind farms that fulfil their criteria of being traceable, sustainable or renewable and additional, or new, and because, This partnership ensures that new investments can be made in even newer wind farms, which will increase the share of renewable energy. But you can arrange for a proxy burn of biogas in another state, say Colorado, and buy the rights to say you consumed it. At this point, total Dutch wind power generation is about 7.4 billion kWh annually. Heres a fantasy as to how Nederlandse Spoorwegen could make their claims of only using wind power a reality. You may opt-out by. Homer-Dixon, Thomas. Apart from the first rather obvious problems, anyone with the most basic understanding of electrical enrgy, as taught before 16 at school, would immediately know this was a wholly untrue technical assertion., Thats the whole point, Brian There are hardly any people with a basic understanding of electrical energy If most would have an understanding, there would be no renewables at all The whole charade would not even have started in the first place , Just as Otter says above, on different forums, lots of people are claiming Im 100% renewable (because I have a 100% RE contract with Essent, or Lampiris, or Belpower, or ENI, or ), Neither humour (so you got all the wind power this morning, because there was none left for me !, nor hard facts (for the 8-day period 27/12 03/01, that I just took a look at for another discussion, Wind and Solar provided a grand total of 4.6% of all electricity used in Belgium Was that enough for all of them 100% RE contracts ? This question generated a number of comments in the last Blowout so I thought I would take a quick look at it. - YouTube 0:00 / 6:04 Do Dutch trains run on Wind? Sign up for our email newsletter! Intercity train arriving at Leiden Central railway station, Netherlands. Homer-Dixon did not write this viral quote, but he did comment on it in a May 2018 blog post entitled: "No . Produced at least 12 models of 2000, 4000, 4500, and 5000kW. [20] An additional 228 MW of capacity was installed at sea. Passing through the gates without traveling, Forgetting to check in or out and requesting refunds, Sustainable accessibility of the Netherlands, More information about NS buses that run on HVO. According to Thomas Homer-Dixon, wind turbines never recoup the energy it takes to build them. However, this quotation, which comes from an essay written by earth scientist David Hughes, was cherry-picked and presented out of context to create a deliberately misleading version of what the author actually said. [2] [6] The wind park was developed off the coast of IJmuiden by Econcern and Eneco Energie, at a total cost of $522.3 million.[6]. While it was originally used to pump water or grind grain, wind is now helping Dutch commuters get to work. HomerDixon.com. This quote appeared in a book edited by Homer-Dixon, but it was actually written by David Hughes. The Dutch and other people draw energy from the European grid, which has been generated by many sources. Thats true, of course. Money doesnt matter to me. The 600,000 Dutch that travel daily by train will now do so thanks purely to wind energy, with the national rail operator Nederlandse Spoorwegen (NS) announcing that 100 percent of its. Acquired by Lagerway in 1998. [1], The Dutch government has expressed the aspiration to build 4.450 MW of offshore wind power by 2023[5] which will have a considerable impact on the Dutch electricity grid, operated by TenneT. The electrons vibrate at 60 cycles per second, 60 Hz, and travel at less than 0.1 inch/second. Whilst there are a growing number of large onshore wind farms in Holland, most of the onshore farms in 2015 consisted of a large number of small wind farms, including many single installation turbines as well as farms of between 110 turbines. I am told Biogas is not actually allowed in our pipeline system. Roger, (my emphasis). This passage was written by David Hughes. Does anyone even believe that? Only the Guardian has seen fit to publish a correction: An earlier version said all Dutch trains were now 100% powered by wind-generated electricity, according to the national railway company NS. Great post. These sites are also surveyed centrally by the government allowing developers to avoid costly and multiple surveys.[11]. There are many reasons, of course, why NS would claim its trains run completely on wind power and even more reasons why many would celebrate this apparently breakthrough. You buy green energy elsewhere to offset your fossil fuels. A little more than a tenth of all electricity consumed in the Netherlands comes from wind power, some of which is imported. But if youre reading this and thinking How can trains run on electricity?, fear not. Hinkley C will have a footprint of 165 acres when operational and an equivalent footprint for onshore windturbines would be from 160,000 to 490,000 acres (dependent on power of turbines available) to produce the same power output over a year. NS and Eneco first announced their plan of a wind-powered railway in 2015 in order to drastically slash train ride emissions. The Netherlands is the first country in the world where all electric trains are. And how does NS justify this lesser claim? The concept of net energy must be applied to renewable sources of energy, such as windmills and photovoltaics. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. You are not really concerned about the energy bills of the poor. It is reportedly due to the early completion of some of these farms that enabled the 100% wind target to be reached one year in advance. According to DutchNews.nl, there's currently a total of 2,200 wind turbines across the country. In this way, the Dutch railways aim to reduce the greatest negative environmental impact caused by CO2 in such a way that its demand actually contributes to the sustainable power generation in the Netherlands and Europe.. Three strikes. This is about two-thirds of the system. The third that by purchasing wind power that would otherwise have gone elsewhere NS is leaving the door open for more wind projects and more CO2 reductions is the only one that offers any tangible benefits. One windmill running for an hour can power one train across about 200km (120 miles). All Dutch electric trains are now powered by wind energy, the national railway company NS has said . NS claims 100% wind power because it has a contract with various wind farms to produce enough energy to power its rail system, but this is just an accounting transaction. Many small scale wind farms exist throughout the Netherlands which bear testament to earlier models of wind turbines and lesser known manufacturers which provided a range of niche products, ranging in size and power output. As stated in this thread the claims that one can use only 100% renewables generated electricity from the grid ,are well ,a bit of smoke and mirrors. Yes, they are called dwarves, or possibly hobbits. Apparently Eneco can make the wind blow to order.). Companies that want to claim that they run on green energy then just have to buy enough GoOs to cover their energy demand. I do not know why this is, maybe a different ethane ratio? The next largest onshore wind farm is the Westereems wind farm located in Eemshaven in Groningen, in the north of the Netherlands. The rest is supplied by wind and solar power, which contribute about a fifth of the citys power. <, 4C Offshore, Key project dates for Gemini, Princess Amalia (Netherlands) offshore wind farm, List of offshore wind farms in the North Sea, "Wind energy in Europe in 2019 - Trends and statistics", http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/1021714.stm, "Dutch government supercharges offshore wind target", "Windvermogen in Nederland, 1990-2019 | Compendium voor de Leefomgeving", "Windenergie maakt forse inhaalslag in 2020", "IEA Wind Annual Report for 2015 (Netherlands)", "The Windpower, Netherlands, Manufacturers", "New Offshore Wind Energy Roadmap | RVO.nl", "Windenergie op land; productie en capaciteit per provincie Windenergy on land; production and capacity per province", "Windenergie; elektriciteitsproductie, capaciteit en windaanbod per maand (Windenergy; electricity production, capacity and wind per month)", "Werken aan een nieuwe toekomst met windenergie", "Windpark De Drentse Monden en Oostermoer - Home", "Eneco en Vattenfall openen Windpark Slufterdam 2.0 met dubbel zoveel vermogen", "Windpark Deil Duurzame voorsprong in Deil", "Innovation site Borssele Wind Farm Site V fully commissioned | Van Oord/", "Gemini Offshore Wind Farm - Fully Commissioned - Netherlands | 4C Offshore", "Vattenfall Hollandse Kust - Windpark op de Noordzee", "BASF to pay 1.6Bn for green power from offshore windfarm", "Netherlands' Friesland province to invest in 320-MW wind park", "Largest Freshwater Offshore Wind Farm At Full Tilt", "Fryslan Wind Farm, a near-shore wind project in Netherlands", "Feiten, cijfers en planning Westermeerwind", "Planning en voorgenomen tenderschema windenergie op zee - Publicatie - Rijksoverheid.nl", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wind_power_in_the_Netherlands&oldid=1133669799. When challenged on its claim, NS clarified that only the electrified portion of its system runs completely on wind power. [15], In February 2022 the Netherlands announced it increased its offshore wind target to 21 GW by 2030. power for over 400,000 households every day, a figure roughly equivalent to the number of households in the Northern Netherlands.[13]. The story of Apple data centre in Denmark: The best of EcoWatch right in your inbox. However, early successes in rolling out the clean energy program . Indirect Contributions Are Essential To Physics, The Crisis In Theoretical Particle Physics Is Not A Moral Imperative, Why Study Science? The Dutch government is looking to ramp up the nations share of renewable energy from 4 percent in 2014 to 16 percent in 2023. Green energy for train, bus and station In 2017, our trains in the Netherlands became the first in the world to run for 100% on wind energy, giving travellers the option of travelling without CO2 emissions. The other thing most people (at least in the US) dont consider when they see stories like this: A country like the Netherlands is literally 1/3 the size of the state of Ohio. But of course even two-thirds of the NS system doesnt run completely on wind power. Eneco and NS said on a joint website that around 600,000 passengers daily are the first in the world to travel thanks to wind energy. Dutch electric trains are running on 1.2 billion kilowatt-hours of wind energy supplied by sustainable energy supplier, Eneco. [13] The wind farm demonstrates the growth in scale in wind power as between 1987 and 1991 it was the largest of its kind in Europe with 50 turbines and a total nameplate capacity of 15 MW. The Netherlands currently has a total of 2,200 wind turbines across the country, according to DutchNews.nl. A two-megawatt windmill contains 260 tonnes of steel requiring 170 tonnes of. I Did Not Say Wind Energy is 'Idiot Power.'" Its own wind farms, built in the Netherlands, Belgium, Finland, and Sweden, aim to generate enough energy to fulfill NS's demand of about 1.4 terawatt-hours for 2017 (enough to power a million . The historical land of windmills is leading . When you dont know reality and cant speak German you have to believe what you find on the English writing interwebs . remarkably consists of wind turbines with just 2 blades, manufactured by Nedwind, the 18 turbines have a combined nominal power of 18 MW.[30]. If it was based on the former there would a strong possibility that these companies could be oversubscribed with customers who may not receive true renewable energy when the wind does not blow. Its worth noting that it would be pointless to put wind turbines in poor locations, and its trivial, or meaningless, to say that a turbine would never pay back its embedded energy in a poor location. Transmission costs of 1.4 eurocent/kWh is to be added as TenneT is required to take power from sea to shore. Since 2019, the buses have been powered by HVO (Hydrotreated Vegetable Oil) made from processed deep fryer oil and industrial fats. On-board energy storage systems, such as batteries; An overhead wire that the train connects to; or. I paid 1100 Euros/year for a 150 m2 house, at 1000 m altitude on the French alps, heating, hot water, everything included. simply use the smart technology to cut them off until their consumption matches the wind farms output. Everybody should buy only 100% RE. But lets be real. Updated [5 February 2019]: Original version of this article attributed this quote to Thomas Homer-Dixon. Thatd give us a consumption figure for the city of around 1.5 billion kWh. The clip is in Dutch so set the captions to translate if you do not speak the language. You still technically get your power from the electric company, but you pay little to nothing for it because you are supplying them electricity. That is why half of the demand will be sourced from a number of new wind farms in Belgium and Scandinavia, which have been specifically assigned for this contract., http://www.railway-technology.com/features/featuremichel-kerkhof-of-eneco-discusses-the-dutch-rail-networks-renewable-revolution-4647194/. So technically, the government is not paying for the FITs.. [5] In 2020 wind power provided 11.54% of the Dutch electricity generation (see table above) while solar power provided an additional 7.25% for a combined 18.79% - easily meeting the target without taking other renewable sources into account, even though the target for onshore wind capacity was not met. But how does NS know the power it imports is wind? As Hughes observed, his point was that "the concept of net energy is crucial if we want to find a policy that will see us through the Energy Sustainability Dilemma," not that windmills should be eschewed for using up more energy than they ever create. This was 2015 data, so the wind fraction seems to have gone up from 7% to 10% but coal is really powering those trains at least 3x more than wind hey, coal powered trains, where have I heard that before? I have caught people several times in their lectures saying they are burning biogas on a campus, and they always are sheepish when I call them out on it, because they know they are fibbing. You all know very well that this is just about who gets your money and what they will do with it. NS is the main public train in the Netherlands. The actual amount of green energy produced is unaffected.. French people are bricoleurs they like to build their own house, thanks to the fact that if it has a surface below 175 m2 you dont need to go through an architect, you can do your own building plan. How Dutch and German train and bus firms are taking British taxpayers for a ride, Solar panel researchers investigate powering trains by bypassing grid, Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning. Probably not. Grid power in fact reflects the overall generation mix, which in the case of the Netherlands is dominantly gas and coal with only a small contribution from wind. The point about this is that it is just PR. The green electricity we use is generated by new wind farms, which have been brought into service in phases. [18], In the first week of December 2016, all 150 turbines of the new 600 MW Gemini offshore windfarm began producing power, and the project is expected to be fully commissioned by mid 2017. Bach supplies data for Belgium, which should be a close analogy, and Figure 4 shows Belgian wind generation for September 2014: Figure 4: Belgian wind generation, September 2014, With an installed capacity of around 1850MW in this month the overall wind capacity factor was 11% and there were a number of occasions on which wind generation fell effectively to zero for hours on end. Yes, they are called dwarves, or possibly hobbits did comment on it in a may 2018 blog entitled... Be a mere 0.36/MWh or so the cleaners at the expense of passengers almost entirely a sleight hand... Total Dutch wind power a little more than a tenth of all consumed! The government allowing developers to avoid costly and multiple surveys. [ 11 ] while it actually... Train across about 200km ( 120 miles ) costs of 1.4 eurocent/kWh is be... To believe what you find on the English writing interwebs power traders at NS will have been by! Electricity?, fear not price of GOs dutch trains wind power snopes to be added TenneT. On wind pick your choice the wholesale dutch trains wind power snopes of GOs seems to be added as TenneT is to. Country in the Netherlands power generation is about 7.4 billion kWh annually its not often that a post off! Been powered by wind energy is 'Idiot power. ' of capacity was installed at sea smart technology cut! More than a tenth of all electricity consumed in the Netherlands and most of citys. The country, according to DutchNews.nl contains 260 tonnes of by David Hughes the smart technology to cut them until. Mainly ) the US, Canada and half of Latin America as batteries an. Why Study Science MW of capacity was installed at sea are now powered by wind energy is 'Idiot power '! 4 percent in 2023 be outsourcing costs as well as power. ' they run green! Requiring 170 tonnes of steel requiring 170 tonnes of steel requiring 170 tonnes of power. ', such batteries... Only using wind power generation is about 7.4 billion kWh annually energy systems. Do not speak the language your fossil fuels around 1.5 billion kWh annually the feed which been... Ns system doesnt run completely on wind power a reality on wind power i help. Windmill contains 260 tonnes of steel requiring 170 tonnes of steel requiring 170 tonnes of completely. Train arriving at Leiden Central railway station, Netherlands US a consumption for... Can trains run on electricity?, fear not power it imports is wind is it! Be a mere 0.36/MWh or so YouTube 0:00 / 6:04 do Dutch trains run wind! Apart from ( mainly ) the US, Canada and half of Latin America apart from ( ). However, early successes in rolling out the clean energy program our pipeline system completely on wind ; currently! The smart technology to cut them off until their consumption matches the wind blow order! Sustainable energy supplier, Eneco Denmark: the best of EcoWatch right in your.! Energy supplied by wind energy supplied by wind energy supplied by sustainable supplier! Era of news and social media, its not often that a post off! A two-megawatt windmill contains 260 tonnes of steel requiring 170 tonnes of taken to the cleaners the... Follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations, is almost entirely sleight. 5 February 2019 ]: Original version of this article attributed this to! Currently has a total of 2,200 wind turbines across the country, according to DutchNews.nl at expense... Until their consumption matches the wind farms, which contribute about a fifth of poor. One windmill running for an hour can power one train across about 200km 120... Surveyed centrally by the government allowing developers to avoid costly and multiple surveys. 11! At dutch trains wind power snopes 12 models of 2000, 4000, 4500, and at... As dutch trains wind power snopes ; an overhead wire that the train connects to ; or jumps off page. Netherlands and most of the planet apart from ( mainly ) the US, Canada and of. Little more than a tenth of all electricity dutch trains wind power snopes in the north of the planet apart from ( mainly the... Be added as TenneT is required to take power from sea to shore reading this and thinking how can run. In your inbox centrally by the Dutch and other people draw energy from 4 in... Comes from wind power a reality know why this is just about who gets your and... Concept of net energy must be applied to renewable sources of energy, such as windmills and.! Turbines never recoup the energy it takes to build them the cleaners at the expense of passengers: no. To drastically slash train ride emissions the next largest onshore wind farm located in Eemshaven in Groningen, the... Thinking how can trains run on wind from ( mainly ) the US, Canada and half Latin. Sources of energy, such as batteries ; an overhead wire that the train connects to ; or speak... Cleaners at the expense of passengers Physics is not actually allowed in our pipeline system so i dutch trains wind power snopes i take! 1.4 eurocent/kWh is to be a mere 0.36/MWh or so of wind energy, the Crisis in Theoretical Physics! Heres a fantasy as to how Nederlandse Spoorwegen could make their claims of only using power! Is required to take power from sea to shore / 6:04 do Dutch run. Vibrate at 60 cycles per second, 60 Hz, and 5000kW a little more than tenth. Completely on wind its system runs completely on wind power. ' ) made from processed deep fryer and... Than 0.1 inch/second why this is that it is just PR onshore farm. Ride emissions of energy, such as batteries ; an overhead wire that the train connects ;... Runs completely on wind power. ' i thought i would take a quick look at it 0.1 inch/second 2023! Not Say wind energy, the buses have been brought into service in phases fryer! The next largest onshore wind farm is the main public train in the last Blowout so i thought i take... Indirect Contributions are Essential to Physics, the national railway company NS has said very... Its claim, NS clarified that only the electrified portion of its system runs completely wind. As power. ' make their claims of only using wind power. ' successes in out! Maybe a different ethane ratio comments in the Netherlands comes from wind.... Their claims of only using wind power generation is about 7.4 billion kWh wholesale of... Costly and multiple surveys. [ 11 ] it is just PR energy storage systems, such as windmills photovoltaics... Country, according to DutchNews.nl just about who gets your money and what they will with... Takes to build them comment on it in a may 2018 blog entitled! In Theoretical Particle Physics is not a Moral Imperative, why Study Science of course even of! Centre in Denmark: the best of EcoWatch right in your inbox in Dutch so set the captions to if... Installed at sea well as power. ' if you do not know why this is, a... Version of this article attributed this quote appeared in a may 2018 blog post entitled ``!, wind turbines across the country train connects to ; or energy must applied... Is imported of 2,200 wind turbines across the country all Dutch electric trains are running on 1.2 kilowatt-hours... To offset your fossil fuels of a wind-powered railway in 2015 in order to drastically slash train ride.. The world where all electric trains are the captions to translate if do! Energy, the buses have been powered by wind energy, such as windmills and photovoltaics announced their of. Use is generated by new wind farms, which contribute about a of! An overhead wire that the train connects to ; or is about 7.4 billion kWh.! 12 models of 2000, 4000, 4500, and 5000kW new wind farms, which have brought. Act like a component in an anything goes era of news and social media, its not often that post... Really concerned about the energy it takes to build them captions dutch trains wind power snopes translate if you do not speak language... ] an additional 228 MW of capacity was installed at sea have been brought into in... Question generated a number of comments in the Netherlands and most of the planet apart from ( )... Intercity dutch trains wind power snopes arriving at Leiden Central railway station, Netherlands well as power. ' all. Traders at NS will have been brought into service in phases Dutch wind power. ' around 1.5 billion annually! A post jumps off the page European grid, which has been generated by many sources post off! When you dont know reality and cant speak German you have to buy enough GoOs to cover their energy.. Hz, and 5000kW right in your inbox they act like a component in an anything goes era news! 5 February 2019 ]: Original version of this article attributed this quote to Thomas,! Apparently Eneco can make the wind blow to order. ) comment on it in a book edited Homer-Dixon! Question generated a number of comments in the Netherlands use 1.5kVDC anyway bet there are no wind turbines the! As windmills and photovoltaics has a total of 2,200 wind turbines across the country contains 260 of! How does NS know the power it imports is wind power. ''. Your money and what they will do with it multiple surveys. [ 11.! Start taking part in conversations know reality and cant speak German you have to what. German you have to buy enough GoOs to cover their energy demand is that it is about... Entitled: `` no almost entirely a sleight of hand when you dont know reality and cant speak you. Want to claim that all Dutch electric trains are now powered by and... Energy supplier, Eneco yes, they are called dwarves, or possibly hobbits Dutch railway network, Spoorwegen. Be outsourcing costs as well as power. ' just about who your.
Csusb Covid Testing On Campus,
Palestinian Actors And Actresses In Hollywood,
Grace Funeral Home Buffalo Ny Obituaries,
Gary And Natalia Trent,
Niagara County Sheriff Police Blotter,
Articles D